Physics/Dr. Lankar                  Name: ________________ section: ______________: grade%: _______
LAB RATIO III
more about ratios
Show that the story of Gulliver can't be true

In Gulliver's travel  the hero arrives in a world with very tiny people. Can a scaled down human being can survive?

Then he arrives in a world with giants. Can a scaled up human being survive ? why or why not ?
Using ratios, you can find out why.
Note: THis lab was inspired by a (PhysicS) class
.
HOME

INTRODUCTION -

In this lab, using ratios, you will find out that we are the right size. A scaled up or scaled down human being is not possible. Unless you change the shape of the human being. A gazelle scaled up can't be unless you change its shape, to become for example an elephant. But this won't be a gazelle anymore.

PROCEDURE: you need a TI. (source: hands-on physics activities - Jossey-Bass edition)

Imagine 3 men. Minuscule Mike (17cm long), Standard Stan (170cm) and, towering Tom (1700cm).

FILL THE BLANKS:
Mike and Tom are scale models of Stan. Same shape but scaled up or down. The scaling is by 10 for Tom. That means that  his arm will be 10 times longer, the leg 10 times longer, every bones 10 times longer.  That means also that the diameter of the bones like the femur will also be 10 times larger.
Any linear dimension (side) will be 10 times stan's corresponding dimensions.
The scaling is by 1/10 for Tom. All linear dimension is divided by 10. Complete the table and we will discuss the results. Understand that the cross-sectional area of our femurs support our weight. REmember what your learnt before :
If you scale up a shape by 10, the lengths are multiplied by __________ (10? 100? 1000?), the areas are multiplied by (10 ? 100 ? 1000?)
and the volumes are multiplied by (10? 100 ? 1000?). Also, as the weight (volume) increases, the ratio surface/weight _____________ !!!
(hint: a mouse has more surface area per weight than an elephant)

MikeStanTom
Height h17cm170cm1700cm
diameter of femur d (see picture below)
hint: diameter is a linear dimension. multiply or divide by 10
____4cm____
radius of femur r
hint: radius = diameter /2
____2cm_____
cross sectional support area of femur A
hint: area = pi x (radius)2 = 3.14 r2
____12.6 cm2_______
volume of entire body V (use Stan's volume to find Mike's and Tom's)
hint:  remember volume is multiplied/divided by ........
____60,000 cm3______
Mass of entire body
hint: mass is like volume. it is multiplied/divided by .........
____60kg_____
weight = mass(kg) x 9.8
hint: multiply the mass by 9.8 from above row
__________N_______
pressure on bones = weight/support area
hint: divide the weight by the cross sectional area of femur
since it is the area of femur that supports our weight.
____47N/cm2____
surface area of the body. use Stan's to find Tom's and Mike's
hint:areas are multiplied/divided by ....... 
____17,000cm2_____
surface area / volume
hint: divide the surface area of the body by the volume. 
_______________

ANALYSIS
1) Observe the table. Tom is scaled up by a factor of ____.
It means all his lengths are multiplied by _____. But because the areas are found by multiplying length by length, when compared to Stan's, all his areas (area of body and area of femur) are multiplied by ______. His body volume is Stan's body volume multiplied by
__________.

2) Le'ts look at the pressure the weight exert on the areas of the femur supporting the weight . The pressure is the force per unit area. More pressure, more damage to a supporting pole. Compare the pressure for the 3 persons. The weight of Tom exerts a pressure ________ times Stan's/
A pressure of 400 N is like 40kg/squared cm or almost 90 pounds/cm2 !!!
What do you think will happen to Tom ?
If you were to build a giant, what changes would you make so the bones don't break ?


3) Let's look at the surface/volume ratio. THat is the surface of skin (border between inside and outside) available per unit of volume.
As the size of the person decreases , from Tom to Mike, the ratio _________. As an animal 's size decreases, its surface ___________ when compared
to the weight. If the surface increases, it means more exchange with the outside world. So there will be more _________ loss.  how many times more ? _______ (compare the ratio surface/volume)
That means that Mike needs to eat _______ times more than Stan to survive.

4) When an animal or object fall 2 forces act on it. The pull due to gravity proportional to the weight.
The drag due to air proportional to the surface of the body and speed.
What would Stan, Tom, and Mike look after falling 900 meters?
hint: as the surface increases, drag increases. As the weight increases, gravity increases

5)A mouse can fall from a 10-story building and walk away. True or false ?

6) If you were to scale up a gazelle by a factor of 2, can you just multiply all the lengths ?
What do you have to do for the animal to survive ?



On the op, the femur of a gazelle,
in the middle the femur of a gazelle scaled up.
The bones of such an animal would collapse.
Bottom the femur of an elephant.
To get a larger animal than the gazelle, you need to change
its __________. So of course, it is not a gazelle anymore !


7) Why do you think the same quantity of water will evaporate faster when placed in a large plate that when placed in a glass ?

8) Some really heavy dinosaurs had spikes on their back. Why ?

9) A cube is 1cm x 1cm x 1cm
Its volume is _______ cm3, its total surface area is _________cm2.  the ratio surface area/volume is S /V = _________
a cube is now 2cm x 2cm x 2cm, the ratio  surface area/volume  is ____________
a cube is 3cm x 3cm x 3cm   the ratio  surface area / volume is ______________
As you increase the side of a cube (one linear dimension), the ratio S/V _______________.
volume is proportional to mass (kg).

so smaller objects have larger __________ ____________ per unit volume.
or smaller objects have larger ___________ _____________ per unit mass. (per kg) (same answer)

10) why steel wool (used to scrub the plates) rust very fast ?

11) why thein French fries cook faster than fat fries?























© haplosciences 2000-2007 -
vente par correspondence jeux éducatifs,  jeux scientifiques clement o ni , jeux educatifs
Amina, Wanikou, mael r oi du mail , laboratoire chimie, fiches e xperiences,  thomas au temps des chevaliers, Pilou  la classe,
 fichiers animation les francas, jeux engrenages singes, engre nages juniors, engr e nages train safari, prismes
microscopes, p rismes, jeux gyzmo sous la mer, jeux engrenages, c o loriage, travaux manuels, animaux, sciences, vente prismes
tub es a essai, apprendre l a nglais , coloriae , anglais maternelle, jeux clémentoni, cahiers maternelle, anglais enfants, anglais petits